Fair Value Calculator vs Fair Price Index
Both estimate what a stock is worth, but in different ways. A fixed blend of three methods: a DCF (50%), comparison with sector peers on P/E, EV/EBITDA and P/S (30%) and analyst price targets (20%), recalculated daily; plus an FPI Rating from 0 to 10 for company quality. Here approach, coverage, quality and price sit side by side, with honest strengths on both sides.
Fair Price Index is a good fit if the big US names are enough for you and you want a free daily fair value with an uncertainty band. Fair Value Calculator covers the world market and computes fair value from several models, without analyst price targets.
| Fair Value Calculator | Fair Price Index | |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | 26 models, weighted by evidence | DCF, peer multiples and analyst targets, fixed weights |
| Coverage | 40,000+ valued stocks | the 100 most followed NYSE and Nasdaq stocks (website) |
| Quality & risk | Quality score from 37 factors + AI moat | varies by provider |
| Evidence | Survivorship-adjusted backtest, openly shown | usually not shown as a backtest |
| Price | free to use, Pro 9.90/month (first month 1) | website free without sign-up; PRO on iOS/Android $2.99/month |
Where Fair Price Index is stronger
- The website is free without sign-up, with a daily fair value and a written report after every quarterly result.
- Every fair value carries an uncertainty band built from volatility, largest drawdown, how far quarterly results strayed from estimates and the spread of price targets.
- Mobile on iOS and Android with a watchlist and alerts at your own buy price, PRO for $2.99 a month.
Where Fair Value Calculator is stronger
- 40,000+ valued stocks worldwide on the website, not only the 100 most followed US names.
- Fair value from 26 models weighted by evidence rather than fixed shares, with no analyst price targets mixed in.
- A screener with fair value as a filter across the whole market and an open, survivorship-adjusted backtest of the method.
Frequently asked questions
Is Fair Value Calculator a good Fair Price Index alternative?
For many investors yes: it gives a valuation and quality verdict from 26 models, free to use and much cheaper. Where Fair Price Index is clearly stronger, we say so openly below.
How does the valuation approach differ?
We run 26 independent models weighted by evidence, plus a separate quality score. A fixed blend of three methods: a DCF (50%), comparison with sector peers on P/E, EV/EBITDA and P/S (30%) and analyst price targets (20%), recalculated daily; plus an FPI Rating from 0 to 10 for company quality.
Does this cost anything?
No. The core of Fair Value Calculator is free and needs no sign-up. Pro is 9.90 a month, first month 1, cancel anytime.
More comparisons
Details about Fair Price Index from publicly available sources as of October 2026, without warranty; products change. Not affiliated with Fair Price Index.